Thunderbolt vs. USB 3.0 at IDF 2011
Posted by Eric Huang on September 19th, 2011
At IDF 2011, we saw a lot of new Thunderbolt peripherals. Mostly storage, but a few docking stations. I will post my pictures of those tomorrow.
It appears that Thunderbolt will remain a chip solution and the Innovator that created Thunderbolt will bring out cheaper chips according to Ars Technica. Also, PC makers like ASUS and Acer may bring out Ultrabooks supporting Thunderbolt. I should point out that Ultrabooks are equivalent to MacBook Air and are more expensive than standard laptops by 50-70% or more.
This also looks to me like Thunderbolt will not be made available for SoC integration.
This means product makers canât build their own IP (and IP providers like Synopsys canât build it either) to bring costs down.
This means Thunderbolt PCs and Peripherals will have an additional ~$25 (my marketing estimate) added to their selling price. This doesnât mean a lot to people buying 30 inch Apple Cinema displays, but people buying portable hard drives tend to try to keep their purchases in the range of $100.
I truly believe that USB 3.0 and Thunderbolt complement each other. Iâm going back to an blog entry I wrote in February âThunderbolt vs. USB 3.0â
Jason Ziller leads the strategic planning and marketing behind Thunderbolt. He also launched USB 2.0 about 13 years ago. Ziller talked to PC Magazine.
âZiller, who was once chairman of the USB Implementorâs Forum, said that USB 3.0 and Thunderbolt were "complementary". "We donât see this replacing USB," he said. âWe see it as complementary to USB⌠Intel will fully support and work with that technology." See the PCMag.com article here.
(Apologies to Jason, thereâs a typo in his last name in the original article in February)
Go back and look at that article on âThunderbolt vs. USB 3.0â and read âHow about some facts about why Thunderbolt will not pass up USB 3.0?â for all the reasons why USB 3.0 will succeed now.
Thunderbolt will succeed in the near term for high end applications by users that can absorb the cost for storage devices. In the long term, docking stations and docking stations in monitors will drive mass adoption. (Pictures of current devices tomorrow).
As Windows 8 launches with USB 3.0 and the chipset makers launch with chipset support, we can be assured USB 3.0 will succeed with over 1 billion devices to be shipped in the next 2 years.
Thunderbolt and the Self Serving Marketing Guy
Yes, this is self serving, but Iâm PMM of the USB 3.0 digital cores so what did you expect?
It doesnât make me less right.
I like to be right once each month. We are already halfway through the month. So this could be it for me.
Iâm now including lots of Hyperlinks back to my articles to:
- Increase my hits, so click away,
- Show some diligence, back up my wild claims
- Make it easier for you to find your way back to my articles, and the original sources on the internet without repeating everything over and over and over. Letâs face it, no one wants to hear the sound of my voice that much.
Iâm really regretting looking at those entries since Iâve finding lots of typos.
Thanks to those people that send me personal e-mails on my Kindle Review Blog Entry and Donuts.
This week: Pictures of ThunderBolt, Booting from a USB Drive with Windows To Go, and new USB Standards
Despite the fact that you know me, please
Subscribe
this URL onto your friend. and tell them to
Subscribe to this Blog, one option to subscribe is as follows:
- Go into Outlook
- Right click on âRSS Feedsâ
- Click on âAdd a new RSS Feedâ
- Paste in the following âhttp://feeds.feedburner.com/synopsysoc/ToUSB?format=xmlâ
- Click on âAcceptâ or âYesâ or whatever the dialogue box says.










I started working on USB in 1995, starting with the world’s first BIOS that supported USB Keyboards and Mice while at Award Software. After a departure into embedded systems software for real-time operating systems, I returned to USB IP cores and software at inSilicon, one of the leading suppliers of USB IP. In 2002, inSilicon was acquired by Synopsys and I’ve been here since. I also served as Chairman of the USB On-The-Go Working Group for the USB Implementers Forum from 2004-2006. 










Trackbacks/Pingbacks
[...] Eric Huang looks at Thunderbolt and USB 3.0 and concludes theyâre complementary. The jury is still out on [...]